A lot of governmental organizations have done a lot of things in the name of “climate change.” Boulder Colorado though, has reached a new low. They sued two energy companies claiming they are responsible for damages the county has suffered from climate change.
Argument for the Petitioners
Oral arguments were heard by the Supreme Court in the case is Suncor Energy v. Boulder Colorado. We start, as usual, with arguments for the petitioners, Suncor Energy.
MR. SHANMUGAM: Thank you, Mr. Chief Justice, and may it please the Court:
This case involves an unprecedented effort to use state law to regulate global conduct. Boulder is suing Petitioners under Colorado law on the theory that their global conduct increased the global use of fossil fuels, which led to an increase in global greenhouse-gas emissions, which contributed to global climate change, which resulted in global harms.
Suncor Energy v. Boulder Colorado – Oral Arguments
It certainly is a a unique argument. After all, the evidence of man-made global warming is questionable at best. To date, none of the models used to predict the dire effects of greenhouse gasses have been anywhere near accurate. Proving that the actions of an energy corporation led to harms in Boulder Colorado would require a level of science that does not exist yet.
Our constitutional system does not permit state law to be used in that manner. The Constitution bars the application of state law to certain inherently federal areas. When the states entered the Union, the plan of the Convention required them to surrender certain preexisting powers in order to ensure each state’s equal sovereignty.
Suncor Energy v. Boulder Colorado – Oral Arguments
While the Constitution does differentiate between state and federal powers, it also requires that the federal government show the power was specifically delegated to the United States. Yes, the states have delegated power to the federal government. However the right to sue for injuries the state suffered is not one of them.
Because of the ambient nature of air and water and the conflicting rights of states, this Court has held for over a century that federal law governs interstate pollution claims. That principle applies with even greater force to claims involving global climate change.
Suncor Energy v. Boulder Colorado – Oral Arguments
There’s one problem with that analysis. The Constitution does not give to the courts the authority to determine jurisdiction, neither does it delegate to the United States the power to regulate pollution, interstate or otherwise.
In addition, the Constitution’s prohibition on extraterritorial regulation precludes a state from extending its law beyond its borders to regulate global conduct with global effects. A state does not have the power to regulate out-of-state conduct based solely on attenuated effects on the state.
Suncor Energy v. Boulder Colorado – Oral Arguments
As I said, the Constitution does define the separation of powers, but I know of no “extraterritorial regulation” clause. That said, there is nothing in the Constitution of any state or the United States that would cause a state to regulate the actions outside their borders. However, Boulder is not claiming to regulate global conduct. Rather they seek a redress to a grievance, but there are problems with that as well.
What is more, the use of state law to regulate global climate change would substantially interfere with the nation’s foreign policy. And far from authorizing the application of state law, the Clean Air Act independently preempts any effort by one state to impose its law on emissions originating in others.
Suncor Energy v. Boulder Colorado – Oral Arguments
That sounds good, except for the fact that the Constitution does not delegate to the United States the power to regulate air, pollution, or other emissions outside of federal property. That means the the Clean Air Act is unconstitutional, and therefore null and void.
If Boulder’s claims are allowed to go forward, some 90,000 municipalities across the country will have the ability to make national and international energy policy by asking juries to impose catastrophic damages on selected fossil-fuel producers.
Suncor Energy v. Boulder Colorado – Oral Arguments
If Boulder’s claims win the day, then companies could be held liable for legal activities because someone believes, without proof, that they were harmed. That would be the real consequence of Boulder winning this suit.
Put simply, that is not the constitutional scheme that the Founders adopted. The Colorado Supreme Court’s judgment should accordingly be reversed.
Suncor Energy v. Boulder Colorado – Oral Arguments
The problem with that argument is it describes no actual controversy involving the Constitution of the United States. Mr. Shanmugam did not quote a single clause from the Constitution in his argument. There is the question of federal law, but that law itself is unconstitutional, meaning this case is not within the jurisdiction of the federal courts.
Argument for the United States
The United States argued as amicus curiae, or friend of the court, on behalf of Suncor.
MS. HARRIS: Mr. Chief Justice, and may it please the Court:
There are two main paths to reversal.
First, we agree with Petitioners, interstate air pollution is an inherently federal area, and Congress hasn’t authorized this suit in the Clean Air Act’s saving clause.
Suncor Energy v. Boulder Colorado – Oral Arguments
Except interstate air pollution is not inherently a federal area, because the Constitution does not delegate such power to the United States.
Second, this suit egregiously exceeds constitutional limits on state authority.
Suncor Energy v. Boulder Colorado – Oral Arguments
Except there is also nothing in the Constitution of the United States that prohibits states from suing for a redress of grievance. That said, there’s another problem here.
Boulder’s theory is that because global climate change causes some Colorado injury, Colorado can hold oil companies liable for all their fossil-fuel activities worldwide.
Suncor Energy v. Boulder Colorado – Oral Arguments
For Boulder’s theory to hold water, the theory of global climate change would have to be proven in the first place. Then it would have to be positively linked to those of fossil fuels, and directly related to injuries in Boulder. That is not only a long chain of proof, but a precarious one.
Argument for Respondents
So what are Boulder’s arguments?
MR. RUSSELL: Mr. Chief Justice, and may it please the Court:
Since the Founding, states have had the power to provide tort remedies for injuries occurring within their borders even when the conduct causing those injuries occurred elsewhere.
Suncor Energy v. Boulder Colorado – Oral Arguments
Yes, states can provide tort remedies, but there has to be a true grievance first. After all, any other case would require the petitioner to prove standing, an actual harm caused by the respondent, and that it can be redressed by the court. none of which has been shown so far.
When somebody in New York defames a citizen of Boulder on national television or somebody in California releases a computer virus on the Internet or a biological virus into the world and it causes mass damage in Colorado, it has never been thought that only federal law can provide a remedy simply because the tortious conduct and the injury occurred in different states, because the harm was widespread, the damages were large, or the defendants were part of an important industry.
Suncor Energy v. Boulder Colorado – Oral Arguments
When someone in New York defames a citizen in Boulder, there is a direct correlation between the actions and an actual harm. That is something that has not been shown so far in this court.
And applying state law to such cases has never been viewed as one state impermissibly projecting its law nationwide. To be sure, specific constitutional provisions limit choice of law and place other constraints on the extraterritorial effects of state law.
But Petitioners invoke none of those provisions here. Instead, they invite this Court to find in the structure of the Constitution a judicial power to declare some subject matters inherently federal and, therefore, preempted not by Congressional enactments but by Congressional silence.
Suncor Energy v. Boulder Colorado – Oral Arguments
Even that would be a problem, since only the Constitution of the United States can delegate a power to said United States, not Congress.
State vs Federal Jurisdiction
Ultimately, the question of the court is whether Boulder’s case falls under state or federal jurisdiction.
JUSTICE KAVANAUGH: Let me finish. Milwaukee I, Milwaukee II, Ouellette, and AEP, which, as I read them together, make crystal-clear that interstate air and water Congress specifically preserves state law.
Suncor Energy v. Boulder Colorado – Oral Arguments
Except none of those are laws, much less the supreme law. These items Justice Kavanaugh listed are court opinions, nothing more. Furthermore, Congress does not preserve state law, Congress passes federal law, which must comply with the supreme law of the land, the Constitution of the United States.
JUSTICE KAVANAUGH: Okay. Now the wrinkle — and this is — I think, goes back to the Chief’s question — the one wrinkle, it’s a little — and Justice Gorsuch’s — a little bit of a problem for you — is that Ouellette did allow the Vermont affected party to sue the New York polluter under New York State law.
What do we do with that? Give me the explanation you would provide for how we deal with that if your side is to prevail and not to go back on choice of law.
MR. SHANMUGAM: So the easiest answer to that, Justice Kavanaugh, is that it is clear that my friend, Mr. Russell, is relying on Colorado law, the law of the affected state. So, if you —
JUSTICE KAVANAUGH: Okay. That resolves this case.
Suncor Energy v. Boulder Colorado – Oral Arguments
If Boulder is basing its case on the Ouellette case it fails. Because in the Ouellette case the Vermont partied sued in New York State under New York law. Here we have a Colorado city trying to sue a Texas company, for actions taken around the world, under Colorado law.
JUSTICE KAVANAUGH: Okay. A different point now.
The Clean Air Act is very significant in terms of the responsibilities it puts on states. We’ve had the cross-state air pollution rule. I had that multiple times on the D.C. Circuit. It came up here. EME Homer sets forth the good neighbor provision, tells the states what they can do. Explain as clearly as you can the conflicts or the inconsistencies or the — or the like that would result if states could do tort suits and were no longer constrained by the good neighbor provision in the way that the Clean Air Act constrains them.
MR. SHANMUGAM: Yeah. So, certainly, as this Court has recognized, we believe that the Clean Air Act establishes a comprehensive scheme for the regulation of air quality in the United States.
Suncor Energy v. Boulder Colorado – Oral Arguments
Except, as I’ve pointed out multiple times, the Clean Air Act is unconstitutional and therefore void. It cannot be the supreme law of the land, so any finding a court has made regarding state responsibilities under the Clean Air Act are also null and void.
JUSTICE KAVANAUGH: Just very precisely, what are the states’ responsibilities that would be in tension with allowing tort suits? If you could answer that specifically.
MR. SHANMUGAM: I think the best place to look is to Section 7411, which is Section 111 of the Clean Air Act, which makes the EPA the primary regulator of stationary sources and gives secondary authority to source states because the states submit plans that specify emissions reductions for point sources within their jurisdiction.
Suncor Energy v. Boulder Colorado – Oral Arguments
Is anyone else annoyed that the most fundamental aspect of this case, the powers of the federal government to regulate the air, is not vested in them by the Constitution? Apparently, neither the attorneys nor the justices of the Supreme Court seem to care.
Justice Thomas asked the attorney for Boulder Colorado if he thought there was a principle that would limit lawsuits against companies for actions taken outside of their state.
JUSTICE THOMAS: If you prevail, is there a limiting principle to whom you can — as to whom you can sue?
MR. RUSSELL: There are a number. So there’s the constitutional limitations on choice of law, which require a sufficient nexus between the state whose law is to be applied and the conduct at issue. There’s the Dormant Commerce Clause. There’s personal jurisdiction limitations.
The question here is not whether anything in the Constitution prohibits this lawsuit but whether the specific theories that they raised and the — the Colorado Supreme Court passed upon below are valid.
Suncor Energy v. Boulder Colorado – Oral Arguments
While Mr. Russell does mention the Constitution, the Dormant Commerce Clause actually isn’t in the Constitution. Rather, it’s a court doctrine that the Commerce Clause, which allows Congress to regulate interstate commerce, prohibits states from passing laws that might adversely impact said commerce.
Rebuttal Argument
Since he was arguing for the plaintiffs, Kannon K. Shanmugam argued first and has the chance to rebut the arguments presented after him.
First, the breadth of Boulder’s theory here is astonishing. First, there is no limit under Boulder’s theory on who could be sued. My friend, Mr. Russell, cites personal jurisdiction and the Dormant Commerce Clause.
But, under Boulder’s theory, Boulder could tag me with personal jurisdiction when I am in Colorado in two weeks and sue me on a nuisance claim for refilling my car and thereby contributing to global climate change. There is simply no limit, and personal jurisdiction provides cold comfort in that regard.
Suncor Energy v. Boulder Colorado – Oral Arguments
While I doubt Boulder County Colorado would sue an individual for purchasing fuel for their vehicle, Mr. Shanmugam does make a point. Without any legal limiting factor, Boulder is claiming the authority to sue anyone they believe contributed to climate change.
[A]nd finally, especially given the foreign affairs implications — and remember that 90 percent of greenhouse-gas emissions occur outside the United States — this is a matter for the political branches on the federal level in the first instance.
Suncor Energy v. Boulder Colorado – Oral Arguments
It does seem rather ridiculous for Boulder to target energy companies whose headquarters are in another state. Mr. Shanmugam’s point about the damage being done primarily outside of the United States seems to fall under his argument that the Clean Air Act is controlling legislation. However, the fact that 90% of something happens elsewhere does not dispose of any actual injury received by said action.
In conclusion, this case and others like it reflect an all-too-regrettable trend of trying to resolve major political issues in court rather than leaving them to the political branches where they belong. Climate change is certainly one of the most pressing issues of the day, but we would submit that this is exactly the wrong way to go about resolving it. And so we would submit that the judgment of the Colorado Supreme Court should be reversed.
Suncor Energy v. Boulder Colorado – Oral Arguments
I agree with Mr. Shanmugam here. This seems to be the latest in a long train of attempts to win in courts what could not be won in legislation. The entire case has the odor of “by hook or by crook” to it. The decision of the Supreme Court of Colorado says more about the citizens of that state than the validity of their argument.
Conclusion
What can we conclude from these arguments? First, the State of Colorado, and Boulder County specifically, have drunk the kool-aid of climate change. I wonder, when Boulder brought the original case to state court, did they provide a single scientifically provable harm caused by climate change, much less Suncor Energy specifically?
However, this case isn’t about Boulder’s claims of injury. Rather it’s about whether or not Boulder can bring a claim under state law for these alleged injuries. Suncor claims that the federal Clean Air Act supersedes the state’s power to hear the claim. While I think the claims in this case are specious at best, the simple fact is that this case does not fall under federal jurisdiction.
The judicial Power shall extend to all Cases, in Law and Equity, arising under this Constitution, the Laws of the United States, and Treaties made, or which shall be made, under their Authority;
U.S. Constitution, Article III, Section 2
This case does not rise under the Constitution of the United States, nor any treaties made under their authority. The sole claim of the authority under the Clean Air Act rises under a law that was not made pursuant to the Constitution, and is therefore null and void. Putting aside the constitutional question, while I did find the right of citizens to sue under the Clean Air Act, I did not find any prohibition on suits at the state level for violation of state law.
All around, this case seems to be disaster piled on top of disaster. First, it appears that the Supreme Court of Colorado ignored the basic rules of tort law and allowed a case where the petitioner does not appear to have standing. Then the respondent, in what appears to be a desperate attempt to save themselves from the abusive state of Colorado, came up with a novel and crazy theory, which the Supreme Court granted cert to hear.
With courts like this, who needs tyrants?